Author Archives: Allysia Doratti

Identity in the Age of Filters: Are We Our True Selves or Just Trending?

It’s 2024, and let’s face it—we’re all curating. We curate our Instagram feeds, our outfits, and even our breakfast. (Who knew a smoothie bowl could be so photogenic?) But here’s the million-dollar question: are we curating ourselves? When teenagers are constantly scrolling through aesthetics, micro-labels, and influencer trends, it makes you wonder—are we still searching for our true selves, or are we just cosplaying whatever’s hot this week?

Welcome to the Identity Crisis, TikTok Edition

As social media has wormed its way into nearly every aspect of our lives, it’s especially giving teens a bit of an identity crisis (to say the least). Gone are the days when teen self-discovery meant listening to emo music or experimenting with questionable hair colors. Nope, now it’s about whether your digital persona should be #cottagecore or #alt.

And that’s where things get tricky. Teens today are stuck in this awkward push and pull between trendy identities and their real, offline selves. One day you’re an aspiring VSCO girl, the next you’re full-on dark academia—and guess what? Neither version quite feels like you. If it seems like a revolving door of personalities and aesthetics, that’s because it kind of is.

Kareena and Emma, two brave souls who’ve stepped up to tackle this phenomenon in their speech on social media and identity, know exactly what this feels like. Back in 2020 (a year we all remember for… reasons), their own sense of self started to unravel, and they’re far from the only ones. Social media was amplifying their identity confusion, and they began to wonder—are they really living as their true selves, or are they just mimicking whatever’s trending on their feeds?

The Illusion of Self (or: Who Am I Today?)

According to Khalil Liouane’s piece on The Illusion of Self in the Digital Age, social media turns our sense of self into an elaborate game of dress-up. Instead of being rooted in experiences, relationships, or even our quirks, we’re now hovering over a “choose your fighter” screen, trying on different identities like outfits for a party we’re not sure we’re invited to.

Liouane breaks down the problem beautifully: as our online presence grows, we start to lose touch with who we actually are. Social media encourages us to become shapeshifters, adopting different personas based on trends, aesthetics, or what will get the most likes. And as teenagers, the pressure to keep up with these trends can feel like trying to solve a Rubik’s cube on a rollercoaster.

This isn’t just about following the latest TikTok dance or updating your Spotify playlist to reflect the vibe du jour. It’s about constantly questioning: Am I more of a “brand” than a person now?

Aesthetic Overload: When Being ‘On-Trend’ Becomes a Full-Time Job

Remember when being a teen was all about awkward phases? Turns out, that’s still the case, but now those phases have names—

and fanbases. From cottagecore to Y2K revival, teens are constantly bombarded with aesthetics, and each one comes with its own rules for how to dress, act, and curate your social media presence. No wonder teens like Kareena and Emma are left questioning, “Wait… who am I again?”

FYI.. I had ZERO idea what cottagecore was until I google it. Here’s a photo that sums up #cottagecore.

The problem is that these trendy identities are fleeting. Today’s clean girl aesthetic is tomorrow’s normcore, and teens are left scrambling to keep up. In the whirlwind of trends, it’s easy to feel like you’re losing yourself. One minute you’re posting pastel pictures of your minimalist bedroom, and the next you’re trading it all in for thrifted grunge sweaters because that’s the new thing.

The Parasocial Problem: When Influencers Become Life Coaches

If aesthetics weren’t confusing enough, let’s throw parasocial relationships into the mix. (Because why not add some emotional confusion to the cocktail?) For those not in the know, parasocial relationships are the one-sided connections people form with celebrities or influencers. And while they may seem harmless—after all, who hasn’t fangirled over a favorite singer—they can become unhealthy when teens begin basing their identities on these influencers.

Think about it: your favorite influencer is living their best life, decked out in the latest trends, and you’re just… scrolling. You start adopting their interests, mimicking their style, and before you know it, you’re losing sight of who you actually are. As Khalil Liouane points out, social media magnifies this phenomenon, making teens feel as though they need to measure up to these digital personas—and that can lead to an endless cycle of self-doubt.

Micro-Labels and Identity Crisis on Steroids

If you thought the pressure to choose an aesthetic was bad, say hello to micro-labels. These super-specific identities can seem like a fun way to express yourself (who doesn’t want a label that perfectly sums them up?), but for teens, they can also add to the overwhelming sense of having to pick who they are, right now. From fashion to personality traits, there’s a label for everything—and choosing wrong feels like social media suicide.

Teens are now under the pressure to define their entire selves based on labels that may only fit one facet of their personalities. And, as Kareena and Emma would tell you, this constant self-categorization leaves teens in a loop of never fully knowing who they are, since the goalposts keep moving.

So, What’s the Solution?

First, breathe. Let’s all admit it—social media is not going anywhere. But what we can do is encourage teenagers (and, let’s be real, ourselves) to step back from the digital whirlwind. Kareena and Emma’s quest to answer, “Am I a reflection of my true identity, or a product of media trends?” is a good starting point for all of us.

The key is to start emphasizing experiential identity building—let teens live, explore, make mistakes, and discover who they are based on real-world experiences rather than the ever-changing tide of TikTok trends. Social media doesn’t have to be the villain of the story, but it shouldn’t be the main character either. By pushing back on the urge to conform to every trend, we can help teens (and ourselves) find more consistency and authenticity in who we are.

Final Thoughts: It’s Okay Not to Be ‘On-Trend’ All the Time

So next time you’re tempted to throw on a micro-label or jump into the latest aesthetic trend, take a pause. Ask yourself: Is this really me, or just something that’s trending? Kareena and Emma’s journey reminds us that finding your identity is supposed to be messy, experimental, and, yes, awkward at times—but that’s part of the fun. Social media may add a layer of complexity, but ultimately, you get to decide who you are—not TikTok, not Instagram, and definitely not the latest #aesthetic.

As we navigate the digital age, remember: it’s okay to step back from the filter and just be yourself—whatever that looks like today.

P.S. I only used ChatGPT for the fun, witty headings this week!

Generative AI: The Ultimate Teacher’s Sidekick

Generative AI—it might sound like something straight out of a sci-fi movie, but trust me, it’s less “robots taking over the world” and more “robots helping you not drown in paperwork.” Picture this: lesson plans created in seconds, grading streamlined, and personalized content suggestions that actually make sense! If you’re a teacher like me juggling a never-ending to-do list, ChatGPT is the sidekick you never knew you needed. I’m not saying it’s perfect, but wow, has it made my teaching life a whole lot easier and even a bit more fun.

Let’s explore how generative AI is transforming education (and why I’m borderline obsessed with it).

What’s Generative AI Anyway? Is It a Robot Butler?

Close, but not quite. Generative AI is like that friend who always has a genius idea when you’re out of steam. Instead of just processing info, it creates. From lesson plans to writing prompts to funny cat memes—AI has a wide range of talents. According to Medium’s AI Overview for Educators, this tool is basically a productivity hack wrapped in cool tech.

In my classroom, ChatGPT is my brainstorming buddy. Got a mixed-level class where some students are breezing through while others need a bit more support? ChatGPT can help me whip up differentiated activities faster than I can drink my morning coffee. Need fresh ways to explain The Pythagorean Theorem for the fifth time this year? Boom, ChatGPT to the rescue! This thing’s like my very own AI Robin to my teaching Batman.

How ChatGPT Made Me a Super-Productive Teacher

Teaching? More like juggling flaming swords while balancing on a tightrope—blindfolded. Between lesson planning, grading, and attempting to squeeze in a lunch break, it can feel impossible to get everything done. Enter ChatGPT, my personal assistant for all things educational.

For those of us teaching without a set curriculum or managing classes with students on different levels, AI has been a game-changer. I can fire off a quick prompt and have a full lesson plan, activity ideas, or even an engaging classroom debate topic ready in minutes. As Learner-Centered’s Blog points out, AI doesn’t replace us as teachers; it just makes us better at focusing on the important stuff—like actually interacting with students, instead of drowning in paperwork.

The Good, The Bad, and the Funny of Digital Citizenship in Classrooms

With great AI power comes great responsibility. In an age where Instagram, Snapchat, and Twitter dominate students’ lives, digital citizenship needs to be front and center in our classrooms. And no, that doesn’t mean lecturing them on the evils of social media for 45 minutes straight (trust me, they’ve heard it). Instead, it’s about making them aware of the consequences of their digital actions.

Take the infamous Harvard University case where students had their admissions revoked for sharing inappropriate memes.

It’s a perfect (and cringe-worthy) example of why teaching digital footprints is crucial. I use ChatGPT to generate discussion prompts and role-playing scenarios where students explore what happens when “just a joke” spirals out of control online. It’s like a

digital soap opera, but with a moral at the end.

The best part? AI helps me break it down for them. We talk about cyberbullying, online ethics, and the everlasting impact of that time they posted their breakfast sandwich with a questionable caption. AI doesn’t just help create lessons—it becomes a tool for teaching digital literacy, letting students reflect on their digital behavior in a way that sticks.

But Wait, Shouldn’t We Ban AI in Schools?

Short answer: Nope. Long answer: Why would we? There’s been a lot of hand-wringing about whether AI tools like ChatGPT should be banned in schools. Some fear that students will use it to slack off or write essays without learning anything (nice try, Jimmy). But The Journal rightly points out that banning AI would be like banning calculators—you’re just delaying the inevitable.

Instead of banning AI, we should teach students how to use it responsibly. In my class, I use ChatGPT to enhance critical thinking. It’s not about copy-pasting answers—it’s about questioning those answers. “Did ChatGPT actually get this right? How do you know? What’s missing?” We’re fostering digital responsibility and helping students understand AI’s potential and its limits.

AI Isn’t Perfect (But Who Is?)

Alright, let’s get real—AI isn’t perfect, and neither am I. Sometimes ChatGPT misinterprets a prompt, and I end up with something more suited for a Shakespearean sonnet than a 9th-grade math class. As MIT’s Tech Review notes, AI can sometimes be biased or just plain weird.

But that’s okay—these “mistakes” are learning moments. I use them to teach my students about media literacy and critical thinking. “Why did the AI say this? Is there a bias here? How can we fact-check this information?” Suddenly, AI isn’t just a tool—it’s a lesson in digital awareness. And hey, it keeps things interesting.

The Three S’s: Safe, Savvy, and Social (With a Side of AI)

Thank you, Mike Ribble, for introducing the three S’s of digital citizenship: Safe, Savvy, and Social. This was mentioned in my last post – go check it out here). It’s the perfect framework for teaching students how to navigate the wild world of the internet responsibly.

  • Safe: We talk about cybersecurity in class—password management, recognizing phishing emails (because no, Prince Nigeria does not need your credit card info), and using AI-generated cybersecurity scenarios to bring these lessons to life.
  • Savvy: I teach students to use AI critically. Whether they’re fact-checking a piece of news or using ChatGPT for homework help, they learn to evaluate the credibility of their sources.
  • Social: We explore the ethics of social media and AI. I create role-play situations using AI where students can explore what happens when digital citizenship goes wrong—and how to make it right.

By integrating the three S’s into the classroom, we make digital citizenship not only informative but also interactive and—dare I say—fun.

Why I’m Obsessed with ChatGPT (and You Should Be Too)

So, yeah, I’m pretty much in love with ChatGPT. It’s made me more productive, more creative, and definitely less stressed. It helps me brainstorm, organize, and even laugh when I need it most. And as I continue learning with AI, I see its potential to make the future of education brighter and more efficient for both students and teachers.

Plus, it gives me time to focus on what I actually enjoy—teaching, connecting with students, and, of course, making sure I have at least one funny meme on hand for class.

 

The Future of Teaching: Powered by AI (and Maybe Coffee)

At the end of the day, AI isn’t here to replace us; it’s here to help us. From helping craft differentiated lesson plans to promoting critical thinking and digital citizenship, AI like ChatGPT is a tool that makes education better. So let’s embrace it, learn alongside it, and have some fun along the way. Because if there’s one thing I’ve learned—teaching with AI? It’s a blast.

Digital Citizenship: Shaping the Future One Element at a Time

Mike Ribble

Last week, we had the privilege of hearing from Mike Ribble, the author and digital citizenship expert who outlined the 9 elements of digital citizenship. It’s easy to feel overwhelmed when considering the breadth of digital responsibility required of today’s students (and even adults). From digital access to cyberbullying, the scope of these elements covers much of what we interact with online daily.

One of the key takeaways from Ribble’s talk was how crucial it is to approach teaching digital citizenship just like any other subject—one step at a time. Just as we wouldn’t throw a math student into calculus without first teaching them basic arithmetic, we shouldn’t expect students to navigate the complexities of the digital world without breaking it down for them.

The Evolving Role of Ribble’s 9 Elements in Digital Citizenship

Ribble’s 9 elements of digital citizenship are designed to help educators and students understand how to engage with the digital world responsibly. But as technology evolves, these elements must also adapt. For example, Ribble talked about Meta’s (formerly Facebook) introduction of a teen Instagram with guardrails—protections that many argue should have existed long ago. These guardrails were a response to growing concerns about how teens navigate social media, but the fact that they were loosened shortly after the app’s launch highlights a broader issue: Are tech companies doing enough to protect young users? And how do we, as educators, ensure that our students are safe, savvy, and social?

In the classroom, we can’t rely solely on tech companies to do the heavy lifting. Ribble’s 9 elements help lay the foundation for responsible digital engagement by focusing on digital safety, literacy, and social responsibility. As we move forward, these elements will likely evolve to include deeper discussions around artificial intelligence, data privacy, and algorithmic biases—topics that are becoming increasingly important in the digital landscape.

The Three S’s: Safe, Savvy, and Social

One of the most memorable aspects of Ribble’s talk was his emphasis on the three S’s of digital citizenship—safe, savvy, and social. These three principles are the bedrock of what it means to be a responsible digital citizen:

  1. Safe: Ensuring students understand cybersecurity, from password management to recognizing phishing attempts, is crucial in an era where cyberattacks are more common than ever.
  2. Savvy: Being digitally literate isn’t just about knowing how to use technology, but understanding how to critically engage with content. This includes distinguishing between reliable sources and misinformation—a skill that documentaries like those mentioned in the readings from Never Gallery Ready and Zanniee emphasize.
  3. Social: Being ethical online involves understanding the impact of one’s actions on others. Whether it’s practicing kindness in a social media comment section or reporting harmful content, students need to be taught the responsibilities that come with having an online presence.

These three pillars encapsulate the broader 9 elements of digital citizenship and make them more accessible to students and educators alike.

Challenges in Implementing the 9 Elements

While Ribble’s framework offers a comprehensive approach to digital citizenship, it’s not without challenges. One of the biggest hurdles educators face is that technology is constantly changing. How do you teach something that seems to evolve overnight? For example, Instagram’s guardrails for teens were loosened shortly after they were introduced, showing how unpredictable the digital landscape can be.

Another challenge is that many educators feel ill-prepared to teach digital literacy, particularly when they themselves might not be fully comfortable with emerging technologies. Ribble emphasized the importance of working with colleagues to grow knowledge and confidence in teaching digital citizenship. This collaborative approach can help educators support each other and create a more unified front in addressing digital issues in the classroom.

Additionally, many students come from homes where digital citizenship isn’t a priority, and parents may not be equipped to guide their children. This places even more responsibility on teachers to fill the gaps in students’ understanding of online safety and responsibility.

Mitigating Challenges

So, how can we mitigate these challenges? For one, we need to shift the mindset that digital citizenship is an “extra” or something that can be taught in a single lesson. It needs to be woven into every aspect of education, much like math or language arts. This gradual, consistent approach ensures that students are building their digital skills over time, rather than in isolated lessons.

Educators also need more support from school administrations in the form of professional development. Providing teachers with ongoing training and resources helps ensure that they are comfortable with both the technology and the pedagogy behind teaching digital citizenship. Ribble’s 9 elements can serve as a guide to structuring these training programs.

Resources and Support for Promoting Digital Citizenship

To effectively promote digital citizenship, schools need a combination of resources, collaboration, and practical tools. Here are a few ideas based on Ribble’s talk and the assigned readings:

  1. Media Literacy Documentaries: The documentaries recommended in the readings from Never Gallery Ready and Zanniee offer powerful insights into media literacy. These resources can help students critically analyze the content they encounter online, from recognizing deep fakes to understanding the influence of social media algorithms.
  2. Collaborative Learning: As Ribble mentioned, educators should collaborate with each other to enhance the teaching of digital citizenship. Schools could create cross-curricular projects where students apply digital citizenship principles across different subjects, reinforcing the idea that these skills are essential in every part of life.
  3. Engaging with Parents: Schools can provide parents with workshops or resources to help them understand their role in promoting digital citizenship at home. This includes teaching parents how to set boundaries around screen time, online privacy, and helping their children develop good online habits.
  4. Safe Social Media Practices: Finally, educators can encourage students to use social media platforms like Instagram, Snapchat, Twitter, and Facebook responsibly by teaching them about privacy settings, reporting harmful content, and recognizing when to log off.

Conclusion: One Element at a Time

Digital citizenship may seem like a daunting task to tackle in today’s educational settings, but as Ribble pointed out, it’s all about breaking it down one element at a time. With a clear focus on safety, literacy, and social responsibility, educators can help students navigate the digital world confidently and ethically. By working together and utilizing the right resources, we can ensure that the future of digital citizenship is bright, empowering students to be safe, savvy, and social—both online and off.

Furthermore, to read more specific examples of how to connect curriculum please visit a previous blog of mine here.

There are lots of blog posts to come, don’t wander too far!

“Snap, Tweet, Post, Repeat: How Not to Lose Your Mind (or Privacy) in the Social Media Jungle”

Ah, social media. That delightful place where we can share everything from our breakfast burritos to our existential crises, all while accumulating likes, followers, and the occasional “Did you really post that?” message from Mom. We live in a world where Snapchat streaks and Instagram likes are social currency, but navigating this jungle can sometimes feel like a video game—except the monsters are online predators, and the boss battle is maintaining your sanity. So, how do we survive and thrive in this pixelated paradise?

Buckle up as we dive into the art of mastering digital citizenship while dodging trolls, sextortionists, and the temptation to tweet your every thought. In a previous course, I was able to speak on my personal usage of tech, read it here.


Digital Citizenship: Because Even Your Cat Meme Has Consequences

First things first—digital citizenship isn’t just some boring phrase your teacher throws around to kill your Snap streak. It’s about being a decent human being online and not turning your Facebook feed into a circus of bad decisions. Take it from the unlucky students at Harvard, who thought sharing offensive memes in a “private” group would never come back to bite them. Spoiler alert: It did. Harvard rescinded their admissions faster than you can say “delete.”

Lesson: What you post online has real-world consequences, even if you think you’re just being “funny”​.

And don’t think you’re safe just because it’s a “finsta” (finsta – fake instagram). Teens often juggle multiple accounts like a social media ninja—public Instagram for the family, and finsta for “the real stuff.” Just remember, even private accounts aren’t always private. If Harvard taught us anything, it’s that screenshots are forever.

Snap, Crackle, Whoops: The Dangers of Snapchat and Sextortion

Let’s be real—Snapchat may be all about “living in the moment,” but those moments don’t always disappear like we hope. In Canada, an alarming rise in sextortion has made it clear that some moments can stick around like an unwanted house guest. Creeps on the internet are baiting teens into sharing compromising photos, and then—BOOM—they’ve got you cornered. They threaten to send those snaps to all your followers unless you cough up some cash. Yikes!!​​

Pro tip: If someone asks for nudes on Snapchat, send them a pic of a hairless mole rat instead (yes, that’s a real sextortion prevention campaign—no joke!). Keep your mole rats handy, folks​.

Instagram Envy and Twitter Tantrums: It’s All Fun and Games Until You Lose Your Chill

Instagram may have started as a photo-sharing app, but let’s face it—now it’s where we go to flex, filter, and live our best fake lives. And then there’s Twitter, where one wrong tweet can turn into a viral disaster faster than you can say #CancelMe. Combine that with the fact that teens’ brains are basically wired to seek instant gratification (thank you, biology), and it’s easy to see why getting lost in the social media shuffle can lead to some pretty poor decisions​ (Global News).

If you’re a parent, don’t just turn your kid’s phone into Fort Knox with monitoring apps. Teach them how to adult online. Apps like ReThink—created by a teenager, naturally—help kids pause before they post something dumb. Because sometimes, all we need is a second to think, “Wait, will this make me look like an idiot?” Read more about this here.

FOMO vs. JOMO: The Art of Logging Off (And Why We Secretly Love It)

FOMO – fear of missing out                                        JOMO – joy of missing out

Here’s where things get interesting. While we’re all obsessed with being connected 24/7, there’s also this trend of glorifying disconnection. The whole “IRL fetish” phenomenon has us bragging about how “off the grid” we are when we keep our phones in our pockets during dinner or manage to survive a day without Facebook. But here’s the kicker: The more we obsess over being offline, the more connected we actually are​.

Remember that walk on Cape Cod that Sherry Turkle talks about, where everyone used to look at the ocean and talk to each other instead of staring at their phones? Well, the irony is that those moments of “disconnecting” often end up being the very thing we post about later. So, are we ever really offline? Spoiler: Nope. Not even close​.

So, How Do You Navigate This Madness?

It’s simple. Treat social media like you would treat a very public diary. Sure, share the good

times, but also keep a filter on what you’re posting (and no, I don’t mean the Valencia filter).

Being a good digital citizen isn’t just about avoiding drama; it’s about recognizing that the lines between online and offline are blurred, and that your digital actions have real-world consequences.

So next time you’re tempted to post that totally hilarious meme, snap a questionable pic, or engage in a Twitter spat, ask yourself: Is this something I’d want my future boss (or grandma) to see? If not, it might be time to rethink.

What Does This Mean for Teachers?

For teachers, the rise of social media and digital platforms like Snapchat, Twitter, Instagram, and Facebook brings a new set of challenges—and opportunities. With students spending significant portions of their day online, educators are in a unique position to guide them through the maze of digital citizenship, teaching them how to balance the freedom of online expression with the responsibility that comes with it. Here’s what all this means for teachers:

1. Digital Citizenship Isn’t Optional—It’s Essential

Digital citizenship is no longer just a buzzword; it’s a critical part of modern education. Students are navigating online spaces daily, and the stakes are high. Teachers need to foster conversations about online safety, privacy, and the ethics of social media use. It’s not enough to tell students not to post inappropriate content—we need to equip them with the tools to make better decisions and manage risks. This includes:

  • Understanding the permanence of online actions: Just like the Harvard students who lost their admissions, students need to grasp that online behavior can have long-term consequences​
  • Encouraging self-regulation: Apps like ReThink give students a pause button before posting something regrettable. Teachers can integrate discussions about such tools into their digital literacy curriculum​

2. Empowering Students to Manage Risks

Instead of focusing solely on restrictions and monitoring, educators can teach students how to manage online risks effectively. Many schools focus on blocking certain websites or enforcing strict social media policies, but this can leave students unprepared for the real-world challenges they’ll face when no one is monitoring their online actions. What’s the alternative?

  • Teach problem-solving and impulse control: Give students strategies for handling risky online interactions, such as sextortion and cyberbullying, which are becoming more common​.
  • Promote critical thinking about online content: Students should be able to recognize manipulative content, phishing scams, and the impact of “like-based” validation on platforms like Instagram and Snapchat​.

3. Encourage Open Dialogue About Online Habits

Many students keep their online lives hidden from teachers (and even parents), but creating a safe space for open dialogue can make a big difference. Students may be struggling with sextortion, cyberbullying, or the pressure of managing their digital identity without feeling comfortable seeking help.

Teachers can:

  • Incorporate discussions on online behavior into daily lessons, linking them to real-world consequences.
  • Model good digital citizenship themselves by discussing their own use of social media responsibly.
  • Facilitate media literacy workshops to educate both students and parents on navigating social media and understanding its influence on mental health and social relationships.

4. Integrate Digital Citizenship Across the Curriculum

Digital citizenship shouldn’t just be a one-off lesson; it should be integrated into multiple aspects of the curriculum. Whether you’re teaching English, history, or science, there are countless opportunities to address how students interact with and present themselves online.

Examples include:

  • Analyzing social media trends and how they reflect society’s values in history or sociology classes.
  • Creating projects where students engage critically with social media platforms, learning about the ethical implications of their digital actions

5. Addressing the Digital Divide

Teachers should also be aware that not all students have equal access to technology. The digital divide can affect how students engage with digital citizenship lessons. Some students may have constant access to the latest smartphones and apps, while others may only get online at school. Being mindful of these disparities allows teachers to create inclusive strategies that ensure all students develop essential digital skills.

6. Professional Development for Teachers

Just as students need digital literacy, so do teachers. Schools should provide ongoing professional development for educators, ensuring they are up-to-date with the latest trends, apps, and risks associated with Snapchat, Instagram, Twitter, and other platforms. Teachers should be prepared to address students’ digital behavior as part of their role as educators.

Final Thoughts: Teaching Digital Citizenship in the Age of Social Media

Ultimately, the goal for teachers is to help students not only survive but thrive in the digital world. That means creating a learning environment where students feel empowered to make informed, ethical, and responsible decisions online. As educators, our role is to guide students through the blurred lines between their online and offline lives, ensuring that they understand the power—and responsibility—that comes with digital freedom.

Incorporating digital citizenship into daily education helps students become more conscious of their actions, fostering safer and healthier online communities. And who knows? Maybe the next time they go to post a mole rat meme, they’ll think twice—and thank you for it.

This is just the beginning, more to come! Check back soon!

Navigating the Future: Integrating Cutting-Edge Technology in Today’s Classroom

Summary of Learning

Today, I am excited to share my learning journey in the EC&I 830 course. This course has been a transformative experience, allowing me to delve even deeper into the intersection of technology and education. Through various debates, assessments, and reflections, I have gained valuable insights I am eager to share.

View my Summary of Learning here:

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1NEYMtTrCBkOiwMqiOyKvU9NzJtAp4rxe/view?usp=drive_link

Engagement with Technology in Education

Throughout the course, we critically examined the role of technology in education and its impact on the classroom environment. One significant theme was the digital divide and its impact on equitable access to educational resources. Reflecting on the blog post titled Bridging the Digital Divide: Reflections on an Equitable Technology Debate, I realized the importance of addressing not just the availability of devices but also reliable internet access and digital literacy training. In my classroom, I plan to advocate for programs that provide devices to students who lack them and to work closely with community organizations to ensure students can access reliable internet. Additionally, incorporating digital literacy into the curriculum will help students navigate and utilize technology effectively and responsibly.

A crucial aspect of engaging with technology in the classroom is ensuring that students have access to the tools and understand how to use them properly. As a teacher, I must teach the proper use and full potential of each educational technology I integrate into my lessons. This includes providing clear instructions, offering hands-on training sessions, and continuously supporting students as they become proficient users of these technologies. By doing so, I can help students maximize the benefits of educational technology and enhance their learning experiences.

The debates on the impact of technology in the classroom were particularly enlightening. Drawing insights from The Great Debate on Technology in the Classroom, it became clear that while technology can enhance learning, it requires careful planning and professional development for effective integration. For example, interactive whiteboards and educational apps can make lessons more engaging and interactive. However, technology should support pedagogical goals rather than distract or disengage students. Therefore, I plan to integrate technology to complement my teaching objectives, such as using digital tools for collaborative projects, simulations, and virtual field trips that enhance the curriculum content.

Artificial Intelligence and Ethical Considerations

Another crucial topic was the integration of artificial intelligence in education. In the blog post AI in Education: Revolutionizing Learning or Risking the Future?, I explored the potential of AI to personalize learning and automate tasks. AI-driven tools can provide personalized learning experiences by adapting to individual student needs and offering real-time feedback, significantly enhancing learning outcomes. For example, I can tailor lessons to fit each student’s pace and learning style using AI-powered platforms like adaptive learning software. However, this potential comes with ethical concerns, such as data privacy, the risk of algorithmic bias, and the need for transparency in AI decision-making processes.

To address these, I will ensure that any AI tools used in my classroom comply with privacy laws and ethical standards, and I will educate my students about the implications of AI in their learning. Additionally, I will emphasize that AI is meant to be used as a tool to guide learning, not as a shortcut to avoid learning. Teaching my students to use these tools properly will help set them on an ethical path, ensuring they understand the importance of using technology responsibly and effectively to enhance their educational journey.

Cell Phones in Education

The impact of cell phones in the classroom was another significant area of exploration. In the blog post The Impact of Cell Phones in the Classroom, I reflected on how cell phones can be both a valuable educational tool and a source of distraction. The key takeaway was the importance of developing clear policies and strategies to manage cell phone use, ensuring they contribute positively to the learning environment. For instance, implementing a ‘bring your own device’ (BYOD) policy can allow students to use their phones for educational purposes such as research, collaboration on group projects, and accessing digital textbooks. However, setting boundaries and establishing guidelines to minimize distractions is crucial, such as designating specific times for cell phone use and encouraging responsible digital citizenship.

I am against banning phones in classrooms because they can offer significant educational benefits. However, I understand that each teacher and their classroom management techniques are responsible for cellphone usage. It is up to teachers to create an environment where cell phones are used productively and where students are taught to use them responsibly.

Overall Reflections

Reflecting on the entire EC&I 830 course, I noted how the course challenged us to think critically about the role of technology in education. It pushed us to consider ethical implications, equity issues, and the long-term impact of our technological choices. The debates and assessments fostered a deeper understanding of the benefits and challenges of integrating technology into our teaching practices. For instance, the debate on the digital divide highlighted the disparities in access. It motivated me to seek innovative solutions, such as partnering with local businesses to provide resources and creating after-school programs focused on digital skills.

It is essential to continue learning about the depths of educational technology and the surrounding context to stay updated with the ever-evolving digital world. This ongoing learning will better equip me to support my students and adapt to new challenges and opportunities.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the EC&I 830 course has been an eye-opener, providing me with valuable insights into the complexities of technology in education. It has equipped me with the knowledge and skills to navigate the digital landscape thoughtfully and responsibly. My biggest takeaway has been the realization that technology, when used thoughtfully and ethically, has the power to transform education and bridge gaps. As I move forward, I am committed to advocating for equitable access to technology, critically assessing new tools, and ensuring that our use of technology always aligns with our educational goals and values. This journey has deepened my understanding and reinforced my commitment to being a reflective and adaptive educator who leverages technology to enhance learning while addressing its challenges head-on.

Thank you for listening. I look forward to continuing this journey of learning and growth with you.

“Keep pushing the limits when it comes to learning more about technology in the classroom. Start the conversations and keep them going. Challenge others’ perspectives and allow them to challenge yours. This is the work that matters for navigating the digital world.” – Ally

The Impact of Cell Phones in the Classroom

Strong arguments exist on both sides of the ongoing debate about the role of cell phones in the classroom. The discussion is crucial as it touches on significant aspects of student learning, mental health, classroom management, and technology integration in education. Here’s a reflection on the key points presented by proponents and opponents of allowing cell phones in schools.

Agree: Cell Phones as a Distraction

Cognitive Load and Physical Separation

One of the most compelling arguments against cell phones in the classroom is their significant impact on students’ cognitive load. A 2017 study demonstrated that even when phones were not in use and notifications were turned off, their mere presence was enough to occupy mental space. This finding suggests that the automatic attention drawn by phones can impede learning, making physical separation crucial for optimal academic performance.

Notification Overload

An experiment conducted by a middle school teacher with her grade six students revealed startling results. Over a period of 40 minutes, 30 students received 662 notifications, averaging 22 notifications per student. This constant barrage of alerts led to increased arousal levels, longer learning times, and significant challenges in covering the curriculum. Moreover, the mental health implications of such frequent disruptions cannot be overlooked, as the constant alerts can cause stress and anxiety among students.

Classroom Distractions

High-school teachers often struggle with the challenge of cell phone use in the classroom. Despite district-wide prohibitions, enforcement tends to be lax, leading to continuous distractions. In response, some districts have adopted non-locking pouches to store phones during class time, a practice gaining national traction. This approach aims to balance the need for focus with the reality of cell phone presence, potentially reducing distractions and improving student engagement.

Disagree: Cell Phones as Educational Tools

Emergency Communication and Professional Use

On the other side of the debate, there are strong arguments for allowing cell phones in the classroom, primarily for their role in emergency communication. Teachers need immediate access to their phones to handle emergencies, communicate with authorities or parents, and manage urgent situations effectively. By using cell phones responsibly, teachers can model appropriate usage for students, demonstrating how to balance technology with professionalism.

Enhancing Learning and Safety

Proponents also argue that cell phones can significantly enhance learning by providing access to digital resources, especially in schools lacking sufficient tablets or computers. Cell phones enable students to contact parents in emergencies and facilitate better communication between students and teachers. Additionally, cell phones can reduce school costs by replacing physical textbooks with digital materials and help streamline administrative tasks, preparing students for a tech-driven future.

Student Perspectives on Mobile Learning

Research by Gikas and Grant (2013) highlights that a majority of students view mobile devices as essential for academic success. These devices help access course content, improve communication, and provide flexibility in learning. However, the research also acknowledges challenges such as technical issues and potential distractions, underscoring the need for effective classroom management and policies to integrate technology smoothly.

Personal Experience and Perspective

From personal experience, cell phones can indeed cause numerous issues in the classroom, including distractions and disruptions. However, I firmly believe that banning cell phones entirely is unnecessary and counterproductive. Effective classroom management is key to addressing these challenges. Teachers should be empowered to manage cell phone use individually, employing strategies that work best for their unique classroom dynamics. By setting clear expectations and modelling appropriate phone usage, teachers can teach students how to responsibly integrate technology into their learning environment.


What are your thoughts on banning cellphones in classrooms?


Conclusion

The debate on cell phones in the classroom is multifaceted, involving considerations of cognitive load, classroom management, emergency communication, and the potential benefits of technology in education. While the arguments against cell phone use focus on distractions and mental health concerns, the proponents highlight the importance of emergency communication and the educational benefits of mobile devices. Balancing these perspectives requires nuanced policies that maximize the advantages of technology while minimizing its potential drawbacks. Instead of outright bans, a more flexible approach that emphasizes individual classroom management can better address the complexities of this issue.

Bridging the Digital Divide: Reflections on an Equitable Technology Debate

Debating the role of technology in creating a more equitable society is both a challenging and enlightening experience. Recently, I found myself on the “agree” side of this debate, tasked with advocating for the equitable use of technology in education. This was no easy feat, especially considering the formidable arguments presented by the “disagree” side, which highlighted the complexities and pitfalls associated with technology integration. Nevertheless, I believe the discussion underscored the crucial role technology can play in leveling the educational playing field when implemented thoughtfully and inclusively.

The Agree Side: Advocating for Equity Through Technology

In preparing for the debate, I drew extensively from several key readings. Suzanne K. Damarin’s (2000) article, “The ‘Digital Divide’ Versus Digital Differences: Principles for Equitable Use of Technology in Education,” was foundational. Damarin argues that addressing the digital divide is not simply about providing access to technology but ensuring that all students can benefit from its use. She introduces five principles for equitable technology use: parsimony, accessibility, multiplicity, separability, and full utility. These principles are designed to guide educators in integrating technology in ways that are cost-effective, inclusive, and tailored to the diverse needs of students.

Additionally, the article “Improving Education for a More Equitable World: Futurist Perspectives” by Li and Liang (2024) highlighted the persistent inequalities in education due to factors like income, gender, and race, exacerbated by crises like the COVID-19 pandemic. This piece emphasized the importance of a comprehensive and interdisciplinary approach to educational improvement, incorporating comparative and international perspectives.

Monica Sulecio de Alvarez and Camille Dickson-Deane (2018), in their work “Avoiding Educational Technology Pitfalls for Inclusion and Equity,” discuss the importance of designing technology integration from a cultural perspective. They argue that educational technology should empower learners and support deep, meaningful learning experiences, avoiding pitfalls like viewing learners as mere consumers of technology or ignoring learners’ autonomy.

The Disagree Side: Highlighting the Complexities

The opposing side raised several critical points. The documentary “Without A Net” discusses the challenges of securing up-to-date devices, connectivity, and teacher training in the USA, highlighting the limitations of simply providing technology without adequate support. The article “Shaping Youth Discourse About Technology: Technological Colonization, Manifest Destiny, and the Frontier Myth in Facebook’s Public Pedagogy” argues that large social media companies perpetuate colonial behaviors by shaping user identities, presenting ethical concerns about technology’s role in education.

The Digital Divide in Canada,” a quantitative study by Statistics Canada, provides data showing the gap in internet use and access, underscoring the disparities between the “haves” and “have-nots.” These points were compelling and underscored the need for a nuanced approach to technology integration.

Personal Reflections: The Private School Experience

As a high school math teacher at a private school where technology is integrated into every classroom, I’ve witnessed firsthand how access to technology can create a more equitable learning environment. Our school mandates that every student has access to a computer, and for those who cannot afford one, the school provides the necessary devices. This policy ensures that all students, regardless of their socioeconomic backgrounds, have equal access to the tools they need to succeed.

In my classroom, technology has transformed the learning experience. Interactive simulations, online resources, and collaborative tools have made math more engaging and accessible for all students. The ability to tailor learning experiences to individual needs through adaptive software has been particularly beneficial, allowing each student to learn at their own pace and style. This experience has reinforced my belief in the potential of technology to foster educational equity when implemented thoughtfully and supported adequately.

Navigating the Debate: An Uncomfortable but Enlightening Journey

Being on the “agree” side of this debate was challenging, especially when faced with the nuanced and well-supported arguments of the “disagree” side. It was uncomfortable to navigate the complexities and acknowledge the legitimate concerns about technology’s role in perpetuating inequalities and ethical issues. However, this discomfort was also enlightening. It underscored the importance of not only advocating for access to technology but also ensuring its effective and equitable use.

The debate highlighted that while technology alone is not a panacea, it can be a powerful tool for promoting educational equity when combined with comprehensive strategies that address connectivity, training, and cultural responsiveness. By focusing on these aspects, we can harness the potential of technology to bridge the digital divide and create a more inclusive and equitable educational landscape.

In conclusion, the debate on the role of technology in education is complex and multifaceted. It requires a balanced approach that considers both the opportunities and the challenges. My experience at a private school has shown that with the right policies and support, technology can indeed lead to a more equitable society. However, this requires ongoing commitment, thoughtful implementation, and a willingness to address the underlying issues that contribute to the digital divide.

AI in Education: Revolutionizing Learning or Risking the Future?

The role of artificial intelligence (AI) in education has sparked a fervent and heated debate among educators, technologists, and policymakers. In a live, well-formatted debate, proponents argued that AI will bring about unprecedented improvements, while critics cautioned against potential risks. This blog post delves into both sides of the debate, examining key arguments and evidence from various sources and providing in-classroom examples of effective AI integration. This is a sensitive and uncharted territory for many of my peers, making the discussion all the more engaging and critical.

The Optimistic Perspective: Transforming Education

AI in Education 4.0

Advocates for AI in education often point to the concept of Education 4.0, a framework that integrates AI to enhance learning experiences and outcomes. An article titled “The Future of Learning: How AI is Revolutionizing Education 4.0” highlights several benefits of AI, such as personalized learning, intelligent tutoring systems, and streamlined administrative tasks. The Fourth Industrial Revolution demands an education system that is adaptive and responsive to individual needs, and AI promises to deliver just that.

Six Ways AI Will Revolutionize Education by 2025

 

The video linked above further explores how AI can transform education. It emphasizes six key areas:

  1. Personalized learning experiences tailored to individual student needs.
  2. Intelligent tutoring systems providing real-time feedback and support.
  3. Streamlined administrative tasks, freeing up educators to focus on teaching.
  4. Predictive analytics to identify and support at-risk students.
  5. Adaptation of curricula to align with market demands.
  6. Breaking down language barriers to make education more accessible globally.

In-Classroom Examples

  1. Personalized Learning Platforms: Platforms like DreamBox and Khan Academy use AI to analyze students’ performance and provide customized lessons and practice problems. For example, a student struggling with fractions might receive additional, varied exercises and immediate feedback, ensuring mastery before moving on to more complex topics.
  2. Intelligent Tutoring Systems: AI-powered tutoring systems such as Carnegie Learning’s MATHia provide individualized tutoring in math. These systems adjust the difficulty of problems based on real-time assessment of the student’s understanding, offering hints and explanations as needed.
  3. Administrative Efficiency: AI tools like Gradescope streamline the grading process by using machine learning to recognize and evaluate student work. Teachers can focus more on providing qualitative feedback and engaging with students rather than spending hours grading assignments.

The Catalyst for Change

Sarah Rubinson Levy, in her TEDx talk “Why AI is the Catalyst We Need to Change Education Forever,” argues that the current education system, rooted in the 19th-century “factory model,” is outdated. She advocates for a shift towards an education system that fosters curiosity, problem-solving, and critical thinking. Levy believes AI can be the catalyst for this transformation, enabling a more engaging and effective learning environment.

Guidance for Generative AI in Education and Research

The UNESCO report “Guidance for Generative AI in Education and Research” by Fengchun and Wayne (2023) provides a comprehensive roadmap for integrating AI into education. The report underscores the importance of ethical guidelines and robust frameworks to ensure AI tools are used effectively and responsibly. It highlights the need for educational stakeholders to embrace AI while addressing concerns such as data privacy and equity.

The Cautious Perspective: Potential Risks and Challenges

Infrastructure Concerns

E. Stefan Kehlenbach’s article “The Impact of Infrastructure: Considerations of GenerativeAI in the Classroom” raises critical questions about the readiness of educational institutions to integrate AI. Kehlenbach argues that without adequate infrastructure, the benefits of AI may be unevenly distributed, exacerbating existing inequalities. The article questions whether the investment in AI is justified, given the potential for significant societal disruption.

Privacy and Ethical Implications

Daniel Buck, in his article “AI is a Serious Threat to Student Privacy,” highlights the ethical concerns surrounding AI’s reliance on extensive personal data. The potential for data breaches and misuse of information poses significant risks to student privacy. Buck calls for stringent policies and robust safeguards to protect sensitive data and ensure ethical AI use in education.

Bias and Inequity

The National Education Association’s article “Does AI Have a Bias Problem?” by Aniya Greene-Santos addresses the issue of bias in AI systems. AI algorithms, often developed by non-diverse teams, can perpetuate existing biases, disproportionately affecting marginalized groups. Greene-Santos emphasizes the need for diverse AI creators and equitable policies to mitigate these biases and ensure fair treatment for all students.

In-Classroom Examples

  1. Protecting Student Data: Teachers using AI tools must ensure student data privacy by adhering to strict data protection protocols, ensuring that personal information is anonymized and securely stored.
  2. Addressing Bias: Educators can use AI tools that have undergone rigorous bias testing, ensuring that feedback and suggestions are fair and unbiased. Regular audits and feedback from diverse user groups can help identify and mitigate biases.

Pros and Cons of AI in Education

An article titled “The Pros and Cons of AI in Education and How it Will Impact Teachers in 2024” provides a balanced view of AI’s potential impact. While AI can enhance learning and administrative efficiency, it also poses threats to job security for educators, risks dehumanizing the learning process, incurs high costs, and fosters over-reliance on technology. The article underscores the irreplaceable role of teachers in fostering human connection and critical thinking.

Conclusion: Navigating the Future of AI in Education

The debate over AI in education is complex and multifaceted. Proponents envision a future where AI revolutionizes learning, making it more personalized, efficient, and accessible. Critics, however, urge caution, highlighting potential risks such as privacy concerns, bias, and the dehumanization of education.

The successful integration of AI in education hinges on careful implementation, strong ethical guidelines, and a dedication to tackling equity and access issues. As we move through this evolving landscape, balancing the potential benefits of AI with a mindful approach to its challenges is vital to ensure that the educational revolution is truly beneficial. To make progress rather than regress, it’s important to view AI as an educational tool rather than a shortcut for students. By teaching them proper usage, we can instill a sense of responsibility in leveraging this powerful technology.

The Great Debate on Technology in the Classroom

DEBATE #1: Technology and its ability to enhance learning

In my recent educational technology class, we had an insightful and engaging debate on whether technology in the classroom enhances learning. My classmates presented their arguments using various scholarly articles, making the discussion well-structured and informative. Here’s a recap of some key points made during the debate and my reflections on the overall experience.

Pro-Technology Arguments

1. Enhanced Engagement and Accessibility:
Proponents of technology in the classroom argued that digital tools significantly enhance student engagement and accessibility. For instance, mobile technology allows students to access educational content anytime and anywhere, making learning more flexible and engaging. Straker et al. (2018) found that mobile technology dominates school children’s IT use in advantaged communities. It can increase engagement in learning activities despite some associated health concerns (Straker, Harris, Joosten, & Howie, 2018). Furthermore, immersive virtual reality-based classrooms have been shown to enhance students’ learning performance in science lessons by providing interactive and engaging experiences (Liu, Wang, Lei, Wang, & Ren, 2020).

2. Improved Academic Performance:
Another point favouring technology was its potential to improve academic performance through personalized learning. Adaptive learning platforms can tailor educational content to individual student needs, helping them learn at their own pace and according to their unique learning styles. The Pew Research Center’s study by Purcell, Buchanan, and Friedrich (2013) highlighted that digital tools positively impact student writing and how writing is taught in schools, suggesting that technology can enhance traditional educational methods (Purcell, Buchanan, & Friedrich, 2013). Additionally, Furió et al. (2015) found that mobile learning can be more effective than traditional classroom lessons in specific contexts, leading to better student outcomes (Furió, Juan, Seguí, & Vivó, 2015).

3. Access to a Wealth of Resources:
Technology provides students with access to a vast array of resources and information that would otherwise be unavailable. The shift to online education during the COVID-19 pandemic highlighted this benefit. Shaikh et al. (2023) discussed how the pandemic necessitated a move to online learning, which, despite cybersecurity challenges, offered students continuous access to educational materials and resources (Shaikh, Khan, Sultana, & Akhter, 2023).

Anti-Technology Arguments

1. Distraction and Multitasking:
Critics argue that technology can be a significant source of distraction for students. Junco and Cotten (2012) found a negative correlation between multitasking with digital devices and academic performance. Students who frequently used Facebook or texted while studying had lower GPAs, indicating that technology might hinder rather than help learning when not used appropriately (Junco & Cotten, 2012).

2. Physical Health Concerns:
Another concern was the potential adverse effects on students’ physical health. Prolonged use of mobile technology can lead to musculoskeletal and visual symptoms among schoolchildren, as Straker et al. (2018) found. This raises questions about the long-term implications of integrating technology into daily classroom activities (Straker et al., 2018).

3. Digital Inequality:
There was also a discussion on digital inequality and how it might exacerbate educational disparities. Warschauer and Matuchniak (2010) analyzed evidence of equity in access, use, and outcomes of new technology. They found that students from disadvantaged backgrounds might not benefit equally from digital tools due to a lack of access and resources. This poses a significant challenge in ensuring that technology enhances learning for all students, not just those who can afford it (Warschauer & Matuchniak, 2010).

My Reflections on the Debate

Watching my classmates debate this topic was incredibly engaging. The structured format allowed both sides to present their arguments clearly and thoughtfully respond to each other’s points. It was fascinating to see how well-researched arguments and real-world examples were used to back up each stance.

I found myself torn between two opposing views. On one hand, the benefits of technology in enhancing engagement and providing personalized learning experiences are undeniable. On the other hand, the concerns about distraction, physical health, and digital inequality are equally compelling.

One particularly intriguing argument came from Harris, Al-Bataineh, and Al-Bataineh (2016), who demonstrated that one-to-one technology programs can significantly enhance student academic achievement and motivation (Harris, Al-Bataineh, & Al-Bataineh, 2016). Additionally, Kris Alexander’s TED Talk highlighted how video games can level up the way we learn by making learning more engaging and interactive (Alexander, 2021).

In conclusion, the debate highlighted that the effectiveness of technology in the classroom largely depends on how it is implemented. It is essential to strike a balance, ensuring digital tools support and enhance learning without introducing new barriers or health concerns. As educators, it is crucial to be mindful of these factors and work towards integrating technology to benefit all students. Technology does indeed enhance learning.

References

Furió, D., Juan, M.-C., Seguí, I., & Vivó, R. (2015). Mobile learning vs. traditional classroom lessons: a comparative study. Journal of Computer Assisted Learning, 31(3), 189–201. https://doi.org/10.1111/jcal.12071

Harris, J. L., Al-Bataineh, M. T., & Al-Bataineh, A. (2016). One-to-One Technology and its Effect on Student Academic Achievement and Motivation. Contemporary Educational Technology, 7(4), 368-. https://doi.org/10.30935/cedtech/6182

Junco, R., & Cotten, S. R. (2012). No, A 4 U: The relationship between multitasking and academic performance. Computers & Education, 59(2), 505-514. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compedu.2011.12.023

Liu, R., Wang, L., Lei, J., Wang, Q., & Ren, Y. (2020). Effects of an immersive virtual reality‐based classroom on students’ learning performance in science lessons. British Journal of Educational Technology, 51(6), 2034–2049. https://doi.org/10.1111/bjet.13028

Purcell, K., Buchanan, J., & Friedrich, L. (2013). The Impact of Digital Tools on Student Writing and How Writing is Taught in Schools. Pew Research Center’s Internet & American Life Project. Retrieved from http://pewinternet.org/Reports/2013/Teachers-technology-and-writing

Shaikh, S., Khan, N., Sultana, A., & Akhter, N. (2023). Online Education and Increasing Cyber Security Concerns During Covid-19 Pandemic. Proceedings of ICAMIDA 2022.

Straker, L., Harris, C., Joosten, J., & Howie, E. K. (2018). Mobile technology dominates school children’s IT use in an advantaged school community and is associated with musculoskeletal and visual symptoms. Ergonomics, 61(5), 658-669.

Warschauer, M., & Matuchniak, T. (2010). New technology and digital worlds: Analyzing evidence of equity in access, use, and outcomes. Review of Research in Education, 34(1), 179-225. https://doi.org/10.3102/0091732X09349791

Alexander, K. (2021). How video games can level up the way you learn. TED.

 

DEBATE #2: Social Media is ruining childhood

My educational technology class recently debated whether social media is ruining childhood. My classmates presented compelling arguments using various scholarly articles and online resources, making the discussion comprehensive and engaging. Here’s a recap of some key points in the debate and my reflections on the overall experience.

Pro-Social Media Arguments

1. Social Connectivity and Support:
Proponents argue that social media provides a platform for children and teenagers to connect with peers, form relationships, and seek support. According to a report by O’Keeffe and Clarke-Pearson (2011), social media allows teens to accomplish tasks crucial to them offline, such as staying connected with friends and family, making new friends, sharing pictures, and exchanging ideas. Social media participation can also offer adolescents more profound benefits that extend into their view of self, community, and the world (O’Keeffe & Clarke-Pearson, 2011).

2. Educational Opportunities:
Another point favouring social media is its potential to enhance learning and provide educational content. Social media platforms can be used to share educational resources, participate in online discussions, and collaborate on school projects. O’Keeffe and Clarke-Pearson (2011) highlighted that middle and high school students use social media to connect on homework and group projects, enhancing their learning opportunities (O’Keeffe & Clarke-Pearson, 2011).

3. Development of Digital Literacy:
Proponents also emphasized the importance of digital literacy in the modern world. Social media use can help children and teenagers develop essential digital skills for future academic and career success. Proficient in navigating social media platforms can also teach critical thinking skills as users learn to discern credible information from misinformation.

Anti-Social Media Arguments

1. Impact on Mental Health:
Critics argue that social media can have a detrimental impact on children’s mental health. The Child Mind Institute points out that excessive social media use can lead to issues such as anxiety, depression, and low self-esteem. The constant comparison with peers and the pressure to present a perfect online image can contribute to these mental health challenges (Child Mind Institute).

2. Shortened Attention Spans:
Another concern is that social media is shortening children’s attention spans. An article from The Queen’s Journal suggests that the constant influx of information and the fast-paced nature of social media can make it difficult for children to focus on longer, more demanding tasks. This can affect their academic performance and ability to engage in deep, meaningful learning (The Queen’s Journal).

3. Cyberbullying and Privacy Issues:
Critics also highlighted the risks of cyberbullying and privacy concerns associated with social media use. Cyberbullying can have severe emotional and psychological effects on children and teenagers. O’Keeffe and Clarke-Pearson (2011) discuss the prevalence of cyberbullying and its potential to cause depression, anxiety, severe isolation, and even suicide (O’Keeffe & Clarke-Pearson, 2011). Furthermore, heavy social media use can negatively impact parent-child relationships, as indicated by Sampasa-Kanyinga et al. (2020), who found that heavy use of social media is associated with greater odds of negative relationships between parents and children (Sampasa-Kanyinga, Goldfield, Kingsbury, Clayborne, & Colman, 2020).

My Reflections on the Debate

The debate on whether social media is ruining childhood was incredibly engaging and thought-provoking. The structured format allowed both sides to present their arguments clearly and thoughtfully respond to each other’s points. It was fascinating to see how well-researched arguments and real-world examples were used to back up each stance.

I found myself leaning towards a balanced perspective. While social media has undeniable benefits, such as fostering connectivity and offering educational opportunities, it poses significant risks to children’s mental health, attention spans, and privacy. The key takeaway for me is that moderation and guidance are essential. Parents, educators, and policymakers must work together to ensure that social media is used to maximize its benefits while minimizing its potential harms.

In conclusion, the debate highlighted that social media’s impact on childhood is complex and multifaceted. It is crucial to approach this issue with a balanced perspective, recognizing social media’s opportunities and challenges. We can help children navigate the digital world safely and effectively by fostering digital literacy and providing appropriate guidance.

Thank you for reading! If you have any thoughts or experiences regarding social media and childhood, feel free to share them in the comments. Let’s continue this meaningful conversation.

References

Child Mind Institute. (n.d.). How Using Social Media Affects Teenagers. Retrieved from https://childmind.org/article/how-using-social-media-affects-teenagers/

O’Keeffe, G. S., & Clarke-Pearson, K. (2011). The impact of social media on children, adolescents, and families. Pediatrics, 127(4), 800-804. https://doi.org/10.1542/peds.2011-0054

Sampasa-Kanyinga, H., Goldfield, G. S., Kingsbury, M., Clayborne, Z., & Colman, I. (2020). Social media use and parent-child relationship: A cross-sectional study of adolescents. Journal of Community Psychology, 48(3), 793-803. https://doi.org/10.1002/jcop.22293

The Queen’s Journal. (n.d.). Social Media is Shortening Our Attention Spans. Retrieved from https://www.queensjournal.ca/social-media-is-shortening-our-attention-spans/

Tech-Enhanced Teaching: A Day in the Life of a Connected Educator

Personal Life
In my personal life, I start the day by checking social media apps like Snapchat, Instagram, TikTok, and Facebook. These platforms help me stay connected with friends and family, follow trends, and get inspiration for creative projects. I often use Canva to design posters, social media posts, and other graphics, which helps me personally and professionally. Whether sharing moments on Instagram stories or creating engaging content for TikTok, these apps are a significant part of my daily routine. I also use X, formerly Twitter, to stay engaged in the Education community, where I share insights, learn from others, and keep up with the latest trends and discussions.

Teaching Life
My day as a teacher is deeply intertwined with technology. I use various digital tools to enhance my students’ learning experience and streamline my workload. Here’s a breakdown of how I integrate these tools into my day:

1. Kahoot and Blooket: These interactive platforms are my go-to for engaging students fun and competitively. I often start the class with a quick quiz or game on Kahoot to review previous lessons or introduce new concepts. Blooket is another favourite for its versatility and how it gamifies learning, keeping students excited and involved.

2. EduAide and Goblin Tools: These AI-powered tools make planning and managing my course load more manageable. EduAide helps me create lesson plans, find resources, and even grade assignments efficiently. Goblin Tools assist with organizing tasks, setting reminders, and ensuring I stay on top of all my responsibilities. I really like the ability to have student utilize a step-by-step process for completing assignments/tasks in a way they understand.

3. Spotify for Podcasters, formerly Anchor: I always provide this as an option for student’s to show their learning. I found it easy to create and share podcasts with me and their peers using this app.

Interactions with Students and Colleagues
Connecting with students and colleagues is seamless, thanks to various email and messaging apps, specifically Microsoft Teams and Microsoft Outlook. These platforms are essential for staying in touch with colleagues, scheduling meetings, and discussing school-related matters.

Balancing Personal and Professional Life
Balancing my personal and professional life involves strategically using technology to manage time effectively. I set aside specific hours for individual activities and disconnected from work-related tasks during these times. Utilizing digital tools helps me stay organized and maintain a healthy work-life balance.

In summary, my day involves leveraging technology for both personal enjoyment and professional efficiency. Technology plays a pivotal role in my daily routine, from engaging students with interactive platforms to staying connected with loved ones through social media.